On the subject of Mini-Notebooks
September 29th 2008
I actually wrote this last week and have been forgetting to post it for some time. Sorry for the delay.
It’s here! My new mini notebook computer is here! I picked it up on Tuesday, and am actually sitting at work right now typing this on it. Is that exciting or what?
I have named it Siren. It is beautiful. Blue. The keyboard is small, but so is the whole darn thing, and it’s the perfect size for toting around. It weighs about a kilo – probably a smidge more with the upgraded battery I opted for. I don’t even notice the weight of it in my backpack. My only complaint so far is that the case is shiny and will be easily and frequently covered with fingerprints. Aah well. You can’t have everything.
Someone in one of the comment threads mentioned wanting to get a new laptop and wanted to know my experience, so I will share the details of my search, for posterity.
The mini-notes are ideal for what I want them for – something I can tote around on the train, that isn’t ungodly heavy in my backpack (even the Macbook “Air” feels like it weighs a ton by comparison. Yes, I walked around Future Shop picking up laptops and putting them back down to see what the weight was like. A note if you do this – the battery pack is the heaviest part of the laptop, and the battery pack usually isn’t attached to the mini-notes in Future Shop or Best Buy.)
I wanted something that I could word process on easily, that had enough space to save my files, that would connect to my other computers (not because I want to connect to the Internet, but because it’s handy when you want to transfer files, or do something like validate your copy of MS Office.)
For this the mini-notes are ideal – light, even with a small hard drives (they can start at about are about 8Gig, more on that in a bit) is more than enough for word processing files. They have lots of memory ports if I want to transfer files from another computer.
Of course, if you’re looking at getting a mini note, you also have to know what it doesn’t have. It doesn’t have a full-sized keyboard. The largest out there is 92%. (at least, that I’ve seen). It doesn’t have a CD drive. Depending on your model, some don’t run Windows because there’s not enough hard drive space. It doesn’t have a full-sized screen. And it’s mostly not an excellent value for the price – you pay a premium for the extra-lightness. This thing is designed for ultra-portability, and web surfing, and that’s about it. Essentially, it’s a student machine, and that’s who they’re marketed toward – it’s something to tote around to all of your classes and write essays on, for slightly less than the price of a regular computer.
I looked at four types of mini-notes – the Asus EEE pc, the MSI Wind, the Acer Aspire One (which is what I ended up buying) and an HP mini-note that I don’t remember the name of. There are more coming out – Dell has announced plans for a mini-notebook, plus rumours of more coming. This is a new market, and if you’re looking now, it might do to wait a few months and see what pricing and options are like then.
Hard Drive – Mini-notes generally have two kinds of hard drives. Some come with a Solid State drive – a flash drive like you have in an iPod. This won’t break if you drop your laptop. It’s a little bit lighter, and runs a little cooler, since it doesn’t have a drive that needs to spin. It takes less battery life (more on that later) to run. The drawback is it holds a lot less memory than a conventional HDD drive.
I went for the computer with an HDD drive and I have 120Gig of space. For about $50 less, I could have had a solid state drive that was about 8Gig. If you’re concerned about memory, the HDD is probably the better option. To my knowledge, the flash drive is only available on the Acer and the Asus computers – the Wind and the HP only come with HDD.
Operating System – HDD drives also will run Windows, frankly because Windows is a memory hog and would take up too much of that precious 8 Gigs on a solid state. The computers that do have solid state drives run a stripped-down version of Linux. If the solid state intrigues you, the Linux interface is definitely worth a look. I actually like the look of the Acer Linux interface better than the Windows interface.
Battery life – From what I can tell, the average battery life for a 3-cell battery is about 3 hours. I paid a premium on my computer to get a 6-cell battery, which has 5-6 hours of work time. Some mini-notes already come with the upgraded battery (I seem to remember the Wind had about 5 hours of life). It’s an important question to ask when you’re looking.
I’m told that the solid state drives require way less battery life – a friend who used an EEEpc said that the solid state would run for 12 hours of solid use without recharging. However, the Acer website promised me about the same battery life for solid state and HDD drives. So I don’t know.
Keyboard – I mentioned smaller keyboards above. This was a big sticking point for me. I wanted to try the MSI Wind because I heard it had the best (and the largest) keyboard, but I couldn’t find a demo model before buying (Locally, the Wind was only available at Microbytes, but I hear that it’s in the latest Business Depot flyer, so that may have changed). I tried the keyboard on the EEE pc, which wouldn’t have been bad, except that the right-hand shift key was on the other side of the pgup key, which meant that every time I wanted to hit shift (I’m a touch typist) I ended up paging back up to the top of a document. That’s aggravating enough to make the computer an absolute no for me. The HP keyboard is really nice and responsive – nicer even than the Acer’s, I think. If keyboard size is important to you, it’s best to check out the models you want at the bigger box stores – they usually have a display model, which your local computer shop might not have. (Microbytes also has display models, but they won’t boot up the notebook for you, which means you can’t open a word processor and see if you’re hitting extra keys)
Price –Prices start at $350 for the Acer, with Linux and an 8Gig flash drive. That’s a Future Shop/Best Buy price. Your local computer store is likely to charge a bit more (I bought from my local computer store. For the extra money, I’d rather not shop at Future Shop, as long-time readers know). The MSI Wind came in at about $575. I don’t remember what the EEEpc goes for. The HP was the most expensive at over $700, which I found a ridiculous price for the value – though if a mini is what you want, and you have the budget for it, the reviews I’ve read say it is the nicest of the lot.
Overall, if you want a laptop, but are going to be using it mostly as a desktop, or are travelling with it but only occasionally, you might want to spend the extra money and get a full-sized laptop. You can get a pretty good one for not too much more than you pay for a mini. The key with the mini is the portability, and you sacrifice on a few things (screen and keyboard size, to name two) to get it.
Myself? I’m very pleased with Siren, and am enjoying the mornings spent typing on the train, and the minutes at lunch hour when I can spend some time typing away to myself.
And if you’re interested, I found this site and its reviews very helpful when making my decision.